NYC Local Law 144: An AI Hiring Compliance Checklist for Employers

Kaylynn Kim, Esq. - Founder/CEO of aiAvenu, Inc.
November 21, 2026
•
5 min read
NYC Local Law 144 AI hiring compliance checklist: bias audit, public posting and candidate notice

Is the AI in your applicant tracking system covered by NYC Local Law 144? Use this checklist to find out.

This checklist helps HR, talent acquisition and legal teams check whether the tools they use to hire for New York City roles, including AI features built into their ATS, are covered by NYC Local Law 144 (LL144), and whether each covered tool has a current bias audit, a posted summary and a candidate notice in place.

LL144 at a glance

LL144 applies when an employer uses an automated employment decision tool (AEDT) to screen candidates for hiring or promotion, and the candidate lives in NYC.

What counts as an AEDT: a tool built on machine learning, statistical modeling, data analytics or AI that produces a score, classification or recommendation that substantially assists or replaces the hiring decision. Under the rules of the NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP), that means the employer:

  1. relies on the output alone,
  2. weighs it more than any other factor, or
  3. uses it to overrule other factors, including human judgment.

Usually covered

  • AI match, fit or ranking scores used to sort or filter applicants
  • Auto-rejection below an AI or algorithmic score threshold
  • AI chatbot or interview tools that score or screen out candidates

Usually not covered

  • Resume parsing that only fills in the candidate profile
  • Fixed knockout rules a person wrote (for example, "must hold a valid guard license")
  • Scheduling, messaging and other administrative automation

The three obligations for each covered tool

  1. Bias audit: an independent audit done within the past 12 months, testing selection or scoring rates by sex, race/ethnicity and their intersections.
  2. Public posting: a summary of the audit results posted on the careers site before the tool is used.
  3. Candidate notice: at least 10 business days before use, NYC-resident candidates are told an AEDT will be used, what qualifications it assesses, and how to request an alternative process or accommodation. Information on data type, source and retention must also be available on request.

Penalties: $500 for a first violation and up to $1,500 for later ones. Each day a tool is used out of compliance counts as a separate violation. DCWP enforces the law, and a December 2025 New York State Comptroller audit criticized enforcement as ineffective, which points to tougher oversight ahead.

Who is responsible: the employer. Your ATS or AI vendor can provide audit support, but you own the posting, the notice, and confirming that the audit fits how you actually use the tool.

Checklist questions

Work through these with the people who run your ATS and your NYC hiring. Any "yes" in the first two groups points to a tool that likely needs the obligations in the third.

AI resume screening and ranking

  • Is your ATS's AI matching, ranking or fit-score feature turned on for NYC roles?
  • Do recruiters sort, filter or decide whom to review based on that score?
  • Are any other AI tools used in hiring (chatbots, assessments, video interviews)?

Auto-rejection and automated decisions

  • Does your ATS, or any connected tool, reject or disqualify candidates without a person reviewing them?
  • What triggers each rejection: a fixed knockout question, an AI or match score below a threshold, or something else?
  • Who set the rejection criteria: a person, or did the system suggest or adjust them?
  • Can a recruiter review or reinstate rejected candidates, and does that happen in practice?
  • Are candidates moved forward automatically (for example, straight to an interview invite) based on a score?
  • Are rejection emails sent automatically, and how soon after the candidate applies?
  • Does any knockout question or filter touch criminal history?
  • Is there a record of why each candidate was rejected (the rule, the score or the reviewer)?

Audit and notice

  • Is there a bias audit from the last 12 months for every covered tool, and who performed it (your vendor, another vendor, an independent auditor)?
  • Does that audit reflect how you use the tool, including your own data where required?
  • Is the audit summary posted on your careers site?
  • Do NYC-resident candidates get notice at least 10 business days before an automated tool is used, including how to request an alternative process or accommodation?
  • Can you answer a written request about data type, source and retention within 30 days?

Ownership

  • Who owns AI hiring compliance: HR, legal or IT?
  • When your ATS vendor releases or enables new AI features, does someone review them before they go live for NYC roles?

Beyond LL144

A tool that falls outside LL144 is not automatically low-risk.

  • Disparate impact: fixed knockout rules can still screen out women or minority applicants at higher rates, which creates exposure under Title VII and New York law. Check pass rates by group, even for rules LL144 doesn't cover.
  • NYC Fair Chance Act: criminal history generally can't be considered until after a conditional offer, and it then requires an individual review. Auto-rejection based on criminal history skips that process, which is a particular risk in industries such as security, where background checks are routine.
  • Other jurisdictions: more states are adopting AI hiring rules. Coverage often follows where the candidate lives, so multi-state employers should review their operations as a whole.

This checklist is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Confirm specific conclusions with your own counsel.

Kaylynn Kim, Esq. is Founder & CEO of aiAvenu.

Related reading

#NYCLL144 #LocalLaw144 #AEDT #BiasAudit #AIinHiring #FairChanceAct #NYCHiring #HRCompliance #ResponsibleAI #HRTech

‍

AI for Smart Hiring
AI Interview

Might be interesting for you

View all

Ready to transform
the way you hire?

Join hundreds of growing teams using ai Avenu and Eva to save time, cut costs, and hire smarter.